Difference between revisions of "Score testing"

Latest revision as of 02:36, 20 January 2023

Unreadable Score extension output in dark mode

Hopefully I can get the Score extension working to produce SVG output on upstream task T49578. The transparent PNG image normally produced needs white background styling otherwise it's unreadable in dark mode.

Update December 2022: my patch was merged! :) now we wait for it to be tested and deployed into Wikipedia. There are a few other issues, including some security and sandboxing concerns, e.g. CVE-2020-17354 (see below). Also, this wiki is running on a 32-bit Debian 10 (Buster), which has LilyPond 2.19 (32 bit builds not supported after 2.22). I'm not game enough to try and compile LilyPond myself, and I'm not even sure Scheme 2 runs in 32-bit(?) so I'm testing the SVG Score output over on my test instance (which is not guaranteed to be up at all times).

Examples

Range of the contrabass trombone, as used on Wikipedia:

${ \new Staff \with { \remove "Time_signature_engraver" } \clef bass \key c \major \cadenzaOn \ottava #-1 \tweak font-size #-2 fis,,,1 \finger \markup \text "poss." \ottava #0 c,,1 \glissando d'1 \tweak font-size #-2 f'1 }$

The Spear motif from Das Rheingold:

$\layout { ragged-right = ##t \context { \Score \omit BarNumber } } \relative g { \override DynamicTextSpanner.style = #'none \override Hairpin.minimum-length = #5 \clef bass \key c \major g2~ \ff g8 f8 e8. d16 c4 b a g f e d c \break b a g f e1~ \dim\! << e1~ { s2 s4 s4 \> } >> e4 \! \p r4 r2 }$

The Summit from Eine Alpensinfonie, which may or may not be a contrabass trombone excerpt, but probably ought to be:

$\relative c, { \time 4/4 \clef bass \key c \major r2 r4\ff g\tenuto c2.\tenuto c4\tenuto g'2.\tenuto g4\tenuto c1 e2~ e4.. b16 a1 g1 c8 r8 r4 r2 \bar "|." }$

CVE-2020-17354

See T259210. Looks like this has been fixed (assuming we're supposed to see the system id in the rendered music); can't reproduce as currently stands, with LilyPond 2.19 (Buster), MediaWiki on REL1_35 and Score on REL1_35.

1. PoC from task:

$\header { tagline = ##f } { \relative { c' } } #(begin (define location 1) (display "With output-def-scope\n") (eval '(system "id") (ly:output-def-scope #{ \midi {} #})) (display "With output-def-lookup\n") ((ly:output-def-lookup #{ \midi {} #} 'system) "id") )$

2. Notehead stencil hack PoC, contributed in comment from LilyPond developer Han-wen Nienhuys:

$\header { tagline = ##f } { \override NoteHead.text = \system \override NoteHead.stencil = #(lambda (grob) ((cdr (assoc 'text (cadr (ly:grob-alist-chain grob '())))) "id") #f) c4 }$

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 [[File:Score_PNG_output_in_dark_theme.png|thumb|Unreadable Score extension output in dark mode]]
-Hopefully I can get the Score extension working to [https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T49578 produce SVG output], instead of the transparent PNG image that needs a white background styling for dark mode otherwise it's unreadable.
+Hopefully I can get the Score extension working to produce SVG output on upstream task [https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T49578 T49578]. The transparent PNG image normally produced needs white background styling otherwise it's unreadable in dark mode.
+;Update December 2022: my patch was merged! :) now we wait for it to be tested and deployed into Wikipedia. There are a few other issues, including some security and sandboxing concerns, e.g. CVE-2020-17354 (see below). Also, this wiki is running on a 32-bit Debian 10 (Buster), which has LilyPond 2.19 (32 bit builds not supported after 2.22). I'm not game enough to try and compile LilyPond myself, and I'm not even sure Scheme 2 runs in 32-bit(?) so I'm testing the SVG Score output over on my [https://mw-master.test.jon.geek.nz test instance] (which is not guaranteed to be up at all times).
 == Examples ==
-Range of the contrabass trombone, as used on Wikipedia:
+Range of the [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contrabass_trombone contrabass trombone], as used on Wikipedia:
 <score lang="lilypond">
    {
@@ Line 26: / Line 27: @@
      b a g f  e1~ \dim\!  << e1~ { s2 s4 s4 \> } >>  e4 \! \p r4 r2
    }</score>
+The Summit from ''Eine Alpensinfonie'', which may or may not be a contrabass trombone excerpt, but probably ought to be:
+<score>
+\relative c, {
+  \time 4/4
+  \clef bass
+  \key c \major
+  r2 r4\ff g\tenuto
+  c2.\tenuto c4\tenuto
+  g'2.\tenuto g4\tenuto
+  c1
+  e2~ e4.. b16
+  a1
+  g1
+  c8 r8 r4 r2
+  \bar "|."
+}
+</score>
+== CVE-2020-17354 ==
+See [https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T259210 T259210]. Looks like this has been fixed (assuming we're supposed to see the system id in the rendered music); can't reproduce as currently stands, with LilyPond 2.19 (Buster), MediaWiki on REL1_35 and Score on REL1_35.
+. PoC from task: <score raw=1> \header { tagline = ##f }
+{
+  \relative { c' }
+}
+#(begin
+  (define location 1)
+  (display "With output-def-scope\n")
+  (eval '(system "id") (ly:output-def-scope #{ \midi {} #}))
+  (display "With output-def-lookup\n")
+  ((ly:output-def-lookup #{ \midi {} #} 'system) "id")
+)
+</score>
+. Notehead stencil hack PoC, contributed in [https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T259210#6368852 comment] from LilyPond developer Han-wen Nienhuys: <score raw=1> \header { tagline = ##f }
+{
+  \override NoteHead.text = \system
+  \override NoteHead.stencil =
+  #(lambda (grob)
+    ((cdr (assoc 'text
+	   (cadr (ly:grob-alist-chain grob '())))) "id")
+    #f)
+  c4
+}
+</score>